Review Type |
Outcome |
Est. Completion Date |
Completed |
Engineering Review - Water
|
No Comments
|
04/01/2025
|
03/31/2025
|
|
Sue Pyles, P.E.
|
|
|
Engineering Review - Water
|
Corrections
|
03/07/2025
|
03/10/2025
|
|
Sue Pyles, P.E.
|
|
Miscellaneous Correction
Corrective Action Required
Please remove the proposed stub, the City does not allow. Provide a cap.
|
|
|
Engineering Review - Sanitary
|
No Comments
|
03/03/2025
|
02/28/2025
|
|
Sue Pyles, P.E.
|
|
Miscellaneous Correction
General:
• Submit an Engineer's Estimate of Probable Construction Costs.
• Submit the SWPPP and a copy of the MDNR Land Disturbance Permit.
• Show and label all easements and right-of-way throughout the plan set.
• Please see previously sent comments with the FDP review. The notes and clarity comments also pertain to this plan set.
**Please submit estimate.
|
|
Miscellaneous Correction
Sheet 5:
• The City’s compacted fill requirement extends to 18” above the top of pipe. It’s fine to require more than the City does, just wanted you to be aware.
• The following MHs do not meet the minimum drop requirement thru structures as shown in Design and Construction Manual Section 6501.D.2.g.: Ex MH “A1”, A4, A5, and A6. Please revise.
• Revise to show the sewer end at MH A7.
**MH A6 has a 0.2’ drop which does not meet the required 0.5’ drop. Please revise.
Ex MH 23-184 has a 0.04’ drop which does not meet the required 0.5’ drop. Please revise.
|
|
Miscellaneous Correction
Sheet 12: Only include standard details applicable to this project.
**This is now Sheet 11. Please remove non-applicable details.
|
|
Miscellaneous Correction
Show and label the water line crossing between Ex MH 23-184 and MH A2 in Profile view.
|
|
Miscellaneous Correction
The labels along the top of the Profile view are cut off. Please adjust for clarity.
|
|
Daniel Fernandez 02/14/2025 2:09 PM Sanitary review not required at this time since applicant has only resubmitted revised water plans, revised sanitary plans to follow
|
Engineering Review - Water
|
Corrections
|
02/26/2025
|
02/27/2025
|
|
Sue Pyles, P.E.
|
|
Miscellaneous Correction
General:
• Submit an Engineer's Estimate of Probable Construction Costs.
• Submit the SWPPP and a copy of the MDNR Land Disturbance Permit.
• Show and label all easements and right-of-way throughout the plan set.
• Please see previously sent comments with the FDP review. The notes and clarity comments also pertain to this plan set.
**Submit estimate.
***Estimate submitted. Will be reviewed when plans are finalized.
|
|
Miscellaneous Correction
Sheets 10-12: Only include standard details applicable to this project.
**It appears that none of the standard details on Sheet 9 are used on this project. Please remove.
|
|
Miscellaneous Correction
Please dimension all separations less than 3’ in Profile view.
|
|
Miscellaneous Correction
There is a “3.5’ Min” label at Sta. 12+00, but the depth shown for the section approximately 12+50-12+75 appears to be less. Please verify and revise if necessary.
|
|
Miscellaneous Correction
Water Utilities has reviewed this plan and provided a mark-up for required revisions. This is saved as "Water Rev1 Markup" in the Documents & Images section.
**Additional comments:
• Do not install valves on either side of the hydrant tees.
• Do not install a valve on the north side of the tee at Sta. 8+41.03.
• Can the hydrant installed at Sta. 7+77.90 be installed on the west side of Commerce or on the Tudor Road portion of the water main to avoid crossing the road with a hydrant?
|
|
|
Engineering Review - Sanitary
|
Corrections
|
01/28/2025
|
01/29/2025
|
|
Sue Pyles, P.E.
|
|
Miscellaneous Correction
General:
• Submit an Engineer's Estimate of Probable Construction Costs.
• Submit the SWPPP and a copy of the MDNR Land Disturbance Permit.
• Show and label all easements and right-of-way throughout the plan set.
• Please see previously sent comments with the FDP review. The notes and clarity comments also pertain to this plan set.
**Please submit estimate.
|
|
Miscellaneous Correction
Sheet 3:
• Please label existing sanitary sewer MHs on this sheet and throughout the plan set as follows: Ex. MH A1 is MH 23-184, Ex. MH B1 is MH 23-183, and proposed MH B2 is MH 23-182.
• It appears that the proposed MH B2 is actually an existing MH. Please revise accordingly on this sheet and throughout the plan set.
• The public sanitary sewer will terminate at proposed MH A7. Beyond that will be private. Please revise accordingly on this sheet and throughout the plan set.
|
|
Miscellaneous Correction
Sheet 5:
• The City’s compacted fill requirement extends to 18” above the top of pipe. It’s fine to require more than the City does, just wanted you to be aware.
• The following MHs do not meet the minimum drop requirement thru structures as shown in Design and Construction Manual Section 6501.D.2.g.: Ex MH “A1”, A4, A5, and A6. Please revise.
• Revise to show the sewer end at MH A7.
**MH A6 has a 0.2’ drop which does not meet the required 0.5’ drop. Please revise.
Ex MH 23-184 has a 0.04’ drop which does not meet the required 0.5’ drop. Please revise.
|
|
Miscellaneous Correction
Sheet 6: Proposed MH B2 is existing. Revise accordingly.
|
|
Miscellaneous Correction
Sheet 7: The City requires service line connections to be made with a wye fitting, not with a tee or MH connection. Please show installation of these wyes in this plan set.
|
|
Miscellaneous Correction
Corrective Action Required
Sheet 12: Only include standard details applicable to this project.
**This is now Sheet 11. Please remove non-applicable details.
|
|
Miscellaneous Correction
Corrective Action Required
Show and label the water line crossing between Ex MH 23-184 and MH A2 in Profile view.
|
|
Miscellaneous Correction
Corrective Action Required
The labels along the top of the Profile view are cut off. Please adjust for clarity.
|
|
|
Engineering Review - Water
|
Corrections
|
01/28/2025
|
01/29/2025
|
|
Sue Pyles, P.E.
|
|
Miscellaneous Correction
General:
• Submit an Engineer's Estimate of Probable Construction Costs.
• Submit the SWPPP and a copy of the MDNR Land Disturbance Permit.
• Show and label all easements and right-of-way throughout the plan set.
• Please see previously sent comments with the FDP review. The notes and clarity comments also pertain to this plan set.
**Submit estimate.
|
|
Miscellaneous Correction
Sheet 3: The existing water lines in the Commerce & Main intersection area are not shown correctly. A drawing showing the existing lines will be sent under separate cover. Please revise this sheet and throughout the plan set.
|
|
Miscellaneous Correction
Sheet 4:
• Show and label the existing 20” water main along NW Main St. in Plan view.
• Label the street names on this sheet and throughout the plan set.
• Label the horizontal bend near Sta. 6+00 in Plan view.
• The City’s compacted fill requirement extends to 18” above the top of pipe. It’s fine to require more than the City does, just wanted you to be aware.
• The private water line connecting to the proposed tee at Sta. 12+07.96 is shown as a 10” line here and an 8” in the FDP plan set. Please reconcile.
• Label existing and profile grade in Profile view.
• The Profile view stops short of the end. Please extend.
• Please include the sanitary crossing near Sta. 8+00 and the storm crossing near Sta. 5+50 in Profile view.
• Please revise the C900 length in Profile view.
• Please use 1-degree joint deflections to reduce the cover depth where over maximum allowed.
|
|
Miscellaneous Correction
Sheets 5-6: A traffic control plan is not required in this plan set. The traffic control plan will be submitted to Public Works with the Right-of-Way Permit application.
|
|
Miscellaneous Correction
Sheets 10-12: Only include standard details applicable to this project.
**It appears that none of the standard details on Sheet 9 are used on this project. Please remove.
|
|
Miscellaneous Correction
Corrective Action Required
Please dimension all separations less than 3’ in Profile view.
|
|
Miscellaneous Correction
Corrective Action Required
There is a “3.5’ Min” label at Sta. 12+00, but the depth shown for the section approximately 12+50-12+75 appears to be less. Please verify and revise if necessary.
|
|
Miscellaneous Correction
Corrective Action Required
Water Utilities has reviewed this plan and provided a mark-up for required revisions. This is saved as "Water Rev1 Markup" in the Documents & Images section.
|
|
|
Engineering Review - Sanitary
|
Corrections
|
09/19/2024
|
09/19/2024
|
|
Sue Pyles, P.E.
|
|
Miscellaneous Correction
Corrective Action Required
General:
• Submit an Engineer's Estimate of Probable Construction Costs.
• Submit the SWPPP and a copy of the MDNR Land Disturbance Permit.
• Show and label all easements and right-of-way throughout the plan set.
• Please see previously sent comments with the FDP review. The notes and clarity comments also pertain to this plan set.
|
|
Miscellaneous Correction
Corrective Action Required
Sheet 3:
• Please label existing sanitary sewer MHs on this sheet and throughout the plan set as follows: Ex. MH A1 is MH 23-184, Ex. MH B1 is MH 23-183, and proposed MH B2 is MH 23-182.
• It appears that the proposed MH B2 is actually an existing MH. Please revise accordingly on this sheet and throughout the plan set.
• The public sanitary sewer will terminate at proposed MH A7. Beyond that will be private. Please revise accordingly on this sheet and throughout the plan set.
|
|
Miscellaneous Correction
Corrective Action Required
Sheet 5:
• The City’s compacted fill requirement extends to 18” above the top of pipe. It’s fine to require more than the City does, just wanted you to be aware.
• The following MHs do not meet the minimum drop requirement thru structures as shown in Design and Construction Manual Section 6501.D.2.g.: Ex MH “A1”, A4, A5, and A6. Please revise.
• Revise to show the sewer end at MH A7.
|
|
Miscellaneous Correction
Corrective Action Required
Sheet 6: Proposed MH B2 is existing. Revise accordingly.
|
|
Miscellaneous Correction
Corrective Action Required
Sheet 7: The City requires service line connections to be made with a wye fitting, not with a tee or MH connection. Please show installation of these wyes in this plan set.
|
|
Miscellaneous Correction
Corrective Action Required
Sheet 12: Only include standard details applicable to this project.
|
|
|
Engineering Review - Water
|
Corrections
|
09/19/2024
|
09/19/2024
|
|
Sue Pyles, P.E.
|
|
Miscellaneous Correction
Corrective Action Required
General:
• Submit an Engineer's Estimate of Probable Construction Costs.
• Submit the SWPPP and a copy of the MDNR Land Disturbance Permit.
• Show and label all easements and right-of-way throughout the plan set.
• Please see previously sent comments with the FDP review. The notes and clarity comments also pertain to this plan set.
|
|
Miscellaneous Correction
Corrective Action Required
Sheet 3: The existing water lines in the Commerce & Main intersection area are not shown correctly. A drawing showing the existing lines will be sent under separate cover. Please revise this sheet and throughout the plan set.
|
|
Miscellaneous Correction
Corrective Action Required
Sheet 4:
• Show and label the existing 20” water main along NW Main St. in Plan view.
• Label the street names on this sheet and throughout the plan set.
• Label the horizontal bend near Sta. 6+00 in Plan view.
• The City’s compacted fill requirement extends to 18” above the top of pipe. It’s fine to require more than the City does, just wanted you to be aware.
• The private water line connecting to the proposed tee at Sta. 12+07.96 is shown as a 10” line here and an 8” in the FDP plan set. Please reconcile.
• Label existing and profile grade in Profile view.
• The Profile view stops short of the end. Please extend.
• Please include the sanitary crossing near Sta. 8+00 and the storm crossing near Sta. 5+50 in Profile view.
• Please revise the C900 length in Profile view.
• Please use 1-degree joint deflections to reduce the cover depth where over maximum allowed.
|
|
Miscellaneous Correction
Corrective Action Required
Sheets 5-6: A traffic control plan is not required in this plan set. The traffic control plan will be submitted to Public Works with the Right-of-Way Permit application.
|
|
Miscellaneous Correction
Corrective Action Required
Sheets 10-12: Only include standard details applicable to this project.
|
|
|
Traffic Review - Streetlight
|
No Comments
|
09/19/2024
|
09/17/2024
|
|
Erin Ralovo
|
|
|
Traffic Review - Streets
|
No Comments
|
09/19/2024
|
09/17/2024
|
|
Erin Ralovo
|
|
|